Passed
| Artist | Song | Percent of Positive Votes |
| Matt & Kim | Daylight | 85 |
Failed
| Artist | Song | Percent of Positive Votes |
| Band Of Skulls | I Know What I Am | 60 |
| Carly Binding | So Radiate | 48 |
| Cut Off Your Hands | Turn Cold | 57 |
| Stephen Marley with Mos Def | Hey Baby | 57 |
| Mr. Gnome | Night Of The Crickets | 67 |
| Paper Route | Last Time | 60 |
| Mark Ronson featuring Kenna | Amy | 49 |
| White Lies | To Lose My Life | 67 |
Poll Question Winners
| Question | Winner | Date Finished |
| What failed Prospect Song Of The Week artist should we give a second chance to? | Minnie Driver | April 7, 2009 |
| From the list below, what would you like to hear more on WBER? | Graham Colton | September 9, 2009 |
| Who would you like to hear more of on WBER? | The Cure | October 21, 2009 |